Can you describe a time you disagreed with your manager?

Question

Can you share an experience where you encountered a disagreement with your manager, detailing the situation, the nature of the disagreement, how you approached resolving the conflict, the communication strategies you employed, and the outcome of the situation?

Accepted Answer

Certainly! Answering this question requires a story that demonstrates your ability to handle disagreements professionally and constructively. Here's an example:

---

In a previous role, I encountered a disagreement with my manager regarding the prioritization of a project. Our team was working on two major initiatives and due to limited resources, it became crucial to determine which one should take precedence. My manager believed that Project A should be prioritized because it was a high-profile task with visibility among senior executives. However, I believed Project B held more strategic importance for the long-term growth of our product line and required immediate attention to stay ahead of a competitive market.

Recognizing the sensitivity of the situation, I approached the disagreement with respect and a solution-oriented mindset. I requested a one-on-one meeting with my manager to discuss my perspective. During our conversation, I calmly outlined my analysis of the strategic importance of Project B. I presented data points and market trends that supported my argument, highlighting how delaying it could potentially result in lost market opportunities. I also acknowledged the importance of Project A and proposed a few strategies to balance the workload, such as delegating some tasks or reallocating resources temporarily.

Throughout the discussion, I utilized active listening and empathy, ensuring I fully understood my manager’s point of view and the external pressures he was facing. This helped in maintaining a positive tone and demonstrating respect for his authority and expertise.

The outcome of the situation was positive. My manager appreciated my proactive approach and the data-driven insights I provided. We collaboratively adjusted our project plan, temporarily shifting some team resources to Project B while setting a phased timeline for Project A. This compromise allowed us to address the immediate market needs without losing sight of organizational priorities. Ultimately, this experience strengthened our working relationship and showcased our ability to navigate conflicts constructively through communication and mutual respect.

---

This answer effectively illustrates the key components interviewers look for: respect and professionalism in disagreements, proactive conflict resolution strategies, effective communication skills, and a positive outcome.

Can you describe a time you disagreed with your manager?

Question Explain

Answer Example

Related Interview Questions