Why might a user need to log in again during a session on a web app with one load balancer and two servers?

Question

You are managing a web application that utilizes a load balancer and is deployed across two servers. Occasionally, users are unexpectedly required to log in again during their sessions. What potential issues or configurations could be causing this behavior, and how might they be addressed to ensure a seamless user experience?

Accepted Answer

If users are being unexpectedly logged out during their sessions on a web application that utilizes a load balancer and two servers, several potential issues or configurations could be causing this behavior. Understanding these issues is key to troubleshooting and resolving them for a seamless user experience. Here are some common causes and their potential solutions:

1. **Lack of Session Stickiness (Session Persistence):**
   - **Issue:** Load balancers typically distribute incoming requests to different servers based on a certain algorithm (e.g., round-robin). Without session stickiness, requests from the same user may be routed to different servers. If session data is stored in the server memory (not shared across servers), this can lead to session interruptions and force users to log in again.
   - **Solution:** Enable session stickiness on the load balancer. This feature ensures that all requests from a single user session are directed to the same server where the user's session is stored.

2. **Session Data Not Shared Across Servers:**
   - **Issue:** As mentioned, if session data is stored locally on a server, users could be directed to a server that doesn't have their session data if stickiness isn't enabled or in the event of a server failure.
   - **Solution:** Use a centralized session management solution. Options include using shared storage solutions, a database, or distributed caches like Redis or Memcached to store session data so that it’s accessible from all servers.

3. **Session Timeout Settings:**
   - **Issue:** Different servers may have different session timeout configurations, or a short session expiry time may be set, requiring users to log back in after a short period of inactivity.
   - **Solution:** Ensure consistent and appropriate session timeout settings across all servers. Adjust the session expiry time to match user expectations and usage patterns, ensuring it is long enough to accommodate typical user interactions.

4. **Server Failover or Restarts:**
   - **Issue:** If a server fails or is restarted (e.g., due to maintenance), active sessions tied to that server will be lost if session stickiness is enabled.
   - **Solution:** Implement session failover solutions such as sharing session data across servers or employing a central session store approach, to prevent sessions from being invalidated due to server-level issues.

5. **Inconsistent Application Code or Configuration:**
   - **Issue:** Differences in application code deployment or configurations between the two servers can lead to session handling inconsistencies.
   - **Solution:** Ensure consistent deployment and configuration management across all servers, preferably using automation tools (e.g., Ansible, Terraform, AWS CodeDeploy) to keep server environments consistent.

6. **Load Balancer Configuration Issue:**
   - **Issue:** There could be misconfigurations in the load balancer settings affecting session handling or routing consistency.
   - **Solution:** Review and ensure that the load balancer is correctly configured to handle sessions and distribute traffic according to the architecture's needs.

Addressing these potential issues typically involves both configuration changes in the system architecture and operational practices to ensure that the session management is robust and user experience is unaffected by the underlying infrastructure.

Why might a user need to log in again during a session on a web app with one load balancer and two servers?

Question Explain

Answer Example

Related Interview Questions